Stocktwits is essentially "Twitter" for stock traders where people post messages related to trading and the market.
I previously mentioned one annoyance I have with using it - seeing people make absolute calls as if they have certain knowledge. That's when they warn someone not to buy or sell with an air of absolute certainty.
A higher level of annoyance occurs when these folks who make absolute calls let everyone know when they made a correct call, but go silent or just ignore past calls when they are wrong. I guess you can chalk this up to human ego but since tweets can't be erased, it's easy to see if someone is being honest about their calls, or just playing games. Maybe people want to be able to brag or are trying to attract followers but only posting one's hits and not misses doesn't really help others or themselves in reality.
The HIGHEST level of annoyance for me is when you have someone taking a leadership role in advising others what to do with absolute calls, insult those taking the other side calling them things like "The Herd", and post these beliefs constantly throughout the day on a regular basis. They post numerous posts patting themselves on the back if right, but if a "perfect just about guaranteed prediction" doesn't pan out, they mention NOTHING about it and just continue on without admitting any mistake like they are still some flawless source of information.

The annoyance level of this type of person inspires me to take action, which led to this post. 
So there's this person on Stocktwits that appears to have appointed himself as a "Market Guru" since from time to time throughout the day he'll post dos and don'ts in how to trade/invest like you would see if you got a book on "Investing Advice for Beginners". Personally, I think posting these tidbits of wisdom isn't really necessary as you would expect people using Stocktwits would already have this knowledge, but I'm seeing there are more than a few folks that are new to trading/investing that seem to like it.
The problem is this guy started making Bearish calls on future index ES since mid July as in warning folks not to go long as it was "high risk", and that anyone long would soon be sorry. I don't mind people having opinions, but he's taking it a step higher by stating his opinions to others as if they are facts that should be heeded and those with counter opinions just don't get it.
Meanwhile, ES slowly starts drifting higher on a regular basis. Days and weeks go by and ES continues to move higher while he continues to frequently post warnings of "imminent demise" for longs with no change in his opinion. Eventually ES is over 20 points higher than his first bearish call, then over 30, 40, 50, and so on. The weeks roll by, and ES continues to move higher with this guy still issuing dire Bear warnings...so if anyone is listening to him and following his advice they are missing a great Bull rally or worse, getting killed by shorting.
At around 40+ points I made a general post about it being a good idea to reconsider calls made if the market moves far enough away to show you "might" be mistaken, and that being too early is really the same as being wrong. It had no effect as he continued to warn away. I guess he didn't pick up on it.
So this goes on past July and through August and we get to September and he's still warning people and criticizing Bulls. Then this month we experience two mega rallies in ES which moves it over 100 points past his original Bearish call. Surely at this point I'm expecting to see him to admit he made a mistake or at least stop posting warnings- but no, he follows the last rally with another post warning about the top being in. 
At that point I've had enough and sent a board message asking him if he was aware that he's been "warning" everyone about an "imminent" Bear market collapse for well over 100 ES points.
His response was that he's a long term trader so his calls are based over the long haul, like as long as a year from now. If that were true, I wouldn't have an issue with it, but that wasn't the case. His posts didn't suggest a far out time, but something much sooner. Thanks to the "magic" of past tweets being saved by StockTwits - I pointed out to him two specific posts he made warning Bulls it would go badly for them in August and that a Bull trap was set.
His response was now ambivalence as in "Well you can't be right all the time."
My point wasn't that he made a mistake, but that he was clearly wrong and never acknowledged it in his tweets and continued to post warnings as usual no matter how far away ES moved against his call.
I mentioned that anyone who is a short term trader following his advice would have missed the entire summer rallies, so being transparent, as in posting that the call was short term or long term along with the cancellation of the short term call would likely be helpful.
At this he apparently got bent out of shape, claimed he has been honest, asked me if I wanted him to quit posting, then "threatened" to stop posting altogether. A very surprising reaction from just one questioned call. 
One of his "devoted followers" saw his threat to quit and suggested he "block me" since my comments had so disturbed him, and that's what he decided to do- I was accused of "badgering" him by his follower. 
"Blocking" means he can't see my messages anymore but I can still see his posts and comment on them if I wish, so I can still call him out for all to see.
The take-away I got from all this is the following:
1) This guy has a very thin skin not to be able to handle a little criticism, not what you would expect from someone trying to be a Market Guru.
2) He was in fact warning people in the short term not to be long in ES, then tried to hide that by saying he has a long term outlook. He doesn't want to admit to making bad calls and gets angered when it's bought to his attention.
3) Rather than be open to discussion, when feeling threatened, he's the "take his marbles and go home" type of guy.
4) Some of his newbie followers would rather rally to his defense than think about my POV even though it's meant to protect new folks like them in particular. I wonder how they are making out following his "expert" advice...
The signs were clearly there that his bear call was wrong but he failed to see it. He relied heavily on technical and sentiment indicators noting whether the market is Bullish or Bearish. The thing is, if it were that simple as to just check the main technical indicators to make a good decision, trading would be so simple you could create a program to do it automatically.
The fact that seems to escape him and so many others is that a market can continue to rise higher despite Bearish indicators ringing alarms, and vice versa. More is needed than just technical signals, but charts show the most reliable information. "Smart Money" usually positions itself in the market first before any major move and good chart detective work can reveal that.
Looking at the ES chart, it was clear ES was headed higher once the resistance of 1400 was broken through.
Technical indicators are accurate for the "long term" and not short term- so if he is a long term investor as he stated, he really shouldn't be making short term calls, especially if he's not willing to own up to them when he's wrong. No shame in being wrong as long as you're upfront. Taking credit for just being right while acting as if one has amnesia when wrong removes true credibility.

Recent Comments