July 13, 2013

  • Suceeding in Trading, Like Many Things, Requires an Iterative Process

    When people I talk to IRL find I actively trade, I often get the “Teach me to trade!” as one of the responses. The feeling comes across that I could sit down with someone and and after a session of explaining all the “secrets”, they’d be newly minted traders immediately able to conquer the markets- like there’s a special “gimmick”  to be made aware of that will make mastering trading a snap.

    Truth is, like most major tasks one sets out to master, it requires an iterative process where you go from a larger “generic” plan and work it down to the specific details necessary to implement it.

     

    For example, the recipe for generating wealth can be summarized by the following:

    1) Find a good paying job

    2) Save more than you spend

    3) Invest your savings

     

    Sounds simple on the surface level, but as they say, the devil’s in the details. Each step breaks down into multiple questions, which in turn generate more sub-steps:

    1) Find a good paying job

    a) What jobs are available?

    a1) Determine list of available jobs

     

    b) What are their qualifications?

    b1) Do you qualify for the job?

    b2) Is advance education needed?

    b2a) What school to go to?

     

    …and so on, and so forth. So those three simple sounding steps can quickly morph into quite a complex and detailed set of tasks as you start formulating a plan of action. It’s clear that attempting to implement that plan will require dedicated time and effort to keep breaking down the steps until you arrive at the specific actions to carry out.

    There will also be some “missteps”, where you proceed on your best guess with the information you have, but it turns out that move was a mistake- requiring you to backtrack a bit. As you proceed, other steps will also become apparent, enabling you to develop further plan details.

    So the question to carrying out this plan becomes are you willing work through the process of fleshing out all the steps of the general plan in order to create a specific plan?

    It can feel daunting when you think about all the steps involved, but if you just take it a step at a time instead on trying to focus on everything, the plan feels much easier to implement.

     

     

    Learning to trade well uses the same process- starting with a general simplified plan, then adding more sub steps and details to get it to the point of execution.

    Of course trading presents a higher level of difficulty because there is a flood of uncertainty and seemingly random market behavior. The initial steps may look something like this:

     

    1) Determine generalized market behavior

    1a) When is it more likely to rise?

    1b) When is it more likely to fall?

     

    The complex/unknown nature of the market can make even forming the initial steps a challenging effort.

    One potential trading pitfall is coming up with an inaccurate simplified plan from the start, as the resulting detailed plan would be doomed from the start.

    Fleshing out the following steps after the simplified steps are created can also be difficult due to the amount of market variables at your disposal. However, once you start moving down a path, creating successive steps become less difficult over time as you figure out what works and what doesn’t. The key is to be disciplined and systematic and persevere through the whole process as you develop greater and greater step details trying to implement your plan. Being systematic and disciplined is crucial to keep from getting bogged down. If a certain planned path doesn’t work, you want to be able to discard it without having it repeated, while keeping the parts of the plan that work. Otherwise, one can keep running in circles, a fate which happens to many potential traders.

    The magic part about putting your brain to work is that even the most complex tasks can be broken down to a simplified and achievable step by step process, as long as you’re committed to see it through. cool

     

     

     

Comments (5)

  • Seems to me, this is good advice for every aspect of our lives, or maybe that was your point. It’s late and my sleep-deprived brain works slowly and unreliably.

  • now that you wrote it like this, it sounds like something i could get into as first a hobby and then a serious side job when ghe kids are older. I love learning, money, and refining and optimization. hmmmm.the linear way you think revealed in your writing makes me feel calm and normal. nerd to nerd. just sayin’. I don’t know if I seem like it, but that’s what I am at heart.

  • @whyzat - You think well even when tired. :) Yes, my point veers towards there not being anything inherently special about learning how to trade as that skill is achieved via the same methods we use for succeeding in life in general. Good old fashioned “try and tray again” perseverance and the ability to learn and improve. @consignedhearts111 - Ah, nerd resonance, haha, <3 =) I think many people who attempt trading make the mistake of trying to find “shortcuts” or “gimmicks” to get around understanding the market movement better, which is why they keep running in circles. If you approach it systematically, you stand a much better chance at reaching your desired goals over time. Your style of thinking will put you ahead of the game.  Even better is there are now “sim accounts” available with play money that are identical in operation to real accounts in every way, so you can get experimentation and practice in without risking anything. Of course, the problem with a sim account is you still need to learn how to deal with fear of loss, which you won’t get with only fake money on the line, but it will allow you to get the mechanics of your trading perfected before deciding to go live. There are also ways to instill “fear” in a sim account once you get to the point of going live.If you do decide to take it on, you’ll see that it’s not terribly complicated at all and more simple than imagined as you refine it down – it’s really just a lot of simple steps that need to be put together in the right sequence.

  • I think this applies to achieving any goal. Thanks for breaking the process down and spelling out each step.

  • Excellent. I will look into that. I am needing something new to get into. I used to write a lot. Goal: to be published in The New Yorker or the like, but it’s very hard to really concentrate and develop it with kids as writing is a very liquid and oblique type of thing. School and checking out the stock market will be good for me as soon as little one starts to sleep longer.I’m very interested in starting a sim account. Thanks for the tip. I am a very organized and methodical thinker when I am approachinb something like this, so it will be fun indeed.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *